Author
|
Topic: Orange Lake and Exchnagers - bad move??
|
BarCol TUG MemberPosts: 1006 From: Newmarket, Ontario, Canada Owner: 2 Aquamarine Villas, 2 Durban Sands and Foxrun! Registered: Dec 2000
|
posted 05-15-2005 09:30
I am sending two very good friends and their families to Orange Lake next March for our Ontario March Break (March 12 through 19). I'm now reading the reviews of this resort and they are, to put it mildly, scathing - poor units for RCI exchngers, very poor housekeeping, tobacco smells in the units and front desk staff that seems unlikely to do anything for you if you aren't an owner.(Yes I should have checked the reviews before booking but we had a great time there several years ago)As theirs are Sunday checkin's in the 2 bedroom sleeps 8 configuration, I'm now starting to panic with these exchanges because my friends are accustomed to nice vacations and I don't want them incovenienced by poor housekeeping, biting insects in the beds, old shopworn accomodations with tobacco smells (and obviously coming back at me with their complaints). Should I be searching around for other properties for them at this late date??? help! ------------------ Barb [This message has been edited by BarCol (edited 05-15-2005).] IP: Logged |
JudiZ TUG MemberPosts: 318 From: New Hampshire, US Registered: Aug 2001
|
posted 05-15-2005 11:35
Hi Barb!My extended family and I trded into OLCC the last weekend in April. Our unit did smell of cigarettes but we bought some Oust and left the windows open for a day and it was fine. Aside from that, we were very pleased with our unit as well as my neice's (hers had not problems at all). Even though we were in an older unit (the furniture was not new, the appliances were a few years old), we thought it was a very nice place. My expeience with the staff was also good - check-in, check-out and maintenance were all polite and quick. When I read reviews, I try to keep things in perspective - some folks just can't be made happy, others dwell on the negative, others just like to complain. Read them all (in the case of OLCC, a lot) and try to get a "sense" of them. We found OLCC to be delightful and I suspect that your friends will too. As an aside, we stayed at the Legacy Golf Resort in February. When I read the reviews, there were several "negative" ones, including one about the bad neghborhood it was near. In a nutshell, this was one of the nicest, well-kept resorts we have ever visited...and we never saw the "bad" neighborhood. It's all persepective. Hope it all works out for you. Judi Z ------------------ "No one can make you feel inferior without your consent." - Eleanor Roosevelt IP: Logged |
timetraveler TUG MemberPosts: 589 From: Orange Lake Country Club, The Ridge of Sedona Golf Resort Registered: Mar 2001
|
posted 05-15-2005 12:26
Barb.....I stay at OL several times each year. I meet and talk to other's staying in the resort each time. Overwhelmingly, the general statements are that this is the best timeshare they have ever stayed at. Now....are you going to get a few disgruntled people, well heck yeah. As in the previous post..I agree that some people can't be pleased no matter what.OL has the most aggressive refurbishing schedule I've personally seen, but we all know that some people check into a unit and have the domestic manners of a pig. They figure..."hey I don't own it so who cares if my 2 year old spills liquid and squashes food all over the place." How many times have you seen this in a restaurant....ie....a table that looks like a nuclear explosion happened on it and around it....with the tell tale sign of a couple of high chairs surrounding the table. I personally have yet to check into any OL unit that I considered to have "bad housekeeping". I'm not saying it hasn't happened, but I know it's rare. You need to read alot of the reviews...and you will see that overwhelminly...the majority of the reviews are glowing. Relax....your family and friends will have a wonderful time, and if they can't find anything to do "onsite"...well let's just say they can't be pleased anywhere. ------------------ Vickie IP: Logged |
sandcastles TUG MemberPosts: 524 From: Terre Haute, In Own at Hurricane House on Sanibel; 2 weeks at PBC at South Seas on Captiva; BWV and BCV with DVC; Foxrun; 2 weekSkiView in Gatlinburg Registered: May 2001
|
posted 05-15-2005 12:40
Barb, It's been about 2 years since we've stayed at OLCC. We were assigned to the older "duplexes or cottages" that most people don't want. However these were our favorite units. The furnishings were a little old but it was very clean. I loved parking at the door and how quiet it was. If we had children with us we might have wanted closer to the activities.I gave a family of 6 a unit to use about 8 years ago. After their week there they stayed in a unit at Vistana that we had vacated for 3 days. They liked Vistana but enjoyed Orange Lake more. I don't think the units at OLCC are as nice as some (mainly HGVC) but I can't imagine anyone being unhappy with them. ------------------ June IP: Logged |
capekong TUG MemberPosts: 720 From: Southeast Missouri Registered: Mar 2004
|
posted 05-15-2005 14:30
We own at OLCC and also have exchanged there. We have not had problems with odors and/or house keeping in the several years that we have been going there. However, we have been in the East Village. IP: Logged |
Dana123me Non MemberPosts: 9 From: Lake Zurich, IL, USA Registered: Oct 2004
|
posted 05-15-2005 14:39
I was given a exchange into the cottages Aug-04. Room 2124. It was the worst, spiders 4 times. Patio table rusted and upside down. Not to mention our unit overlooked 192, light fixture in the foyer missing glass, and a wheelchair in the dining room. I could go on but will not.
IP: Logged |
Dori TUG MemberPosts: 1059 From: Scarborough, Ontario, Canada , Owner at Harbour Inn and Resort Club, Brechin, Ontario and a Lowveld week Registered: Dec 2000
|
posted 05-15-2005 18:40
Hi Barb,Mike and I stayed at OL a few years ago, when you and David and Mike and Nancy were there as well. We loved the Tennis Villas. Having said that, my brother and sister-in-law were there in February and stayed in the two-story villas on Kem Way. We visited and were surprised to find their unit dark and dingy. I was not impressed with these tired-looking units. I hear that the new section is very nice. I'm not sure if it is East or North Village. Dori IP: Logged |
timetraveler TUG MemberPosts: 589 From: Orange Lake Country Club, The Ridge of Sedona Golf Resort Registered: Mar 2001
|
posted 05-15-2005 19:57
quote: Originally posted by Dana123me: I was given a exchange into the cottages Aug-04. Room 2124. It was the worst, spiders 4 times. Patio table rusted and upside down. Not to mention our unit overlooked 192, light fixture in the foyer missing glass, and a wheelchair in the dining room. I could go on but will not.
Mary....your description sounds horrific! As a very involved owner, I'm quite obviously upset. Did you happen to immediately call back down to the front desk? Or head right back up to the office and discuss the units condition? I just cannot imagine OL deliberately placing a guest in a unit in that kind of condition. It sounds to me like this unit was actually not being used, and was on the refurbishing schedule. But somehow, the unit had not been pulled from the reservation system. ------------------ Vickie IP: Logged |
Debbyd57 TUG MemberPosts: 347 From: Port Orchard, Wa-owner at Brookes Hill, Fairfield and Worldmark Registered: May 2002
|
posted 05-15-2005 23:46
When we exchanged into Orange Lake our 1st unit was on Kern Way and when we walked in the unit it was very smoky and the handle for the microwave was laying on the table also the unit furnishings were pretty worn out. We went back to the check in area and ask if anything else was available and they gave us a unit in the East Village That unit was incredible and we realy enjoyed our stay there. If we would have been stuck in the other unit I do not think we would have enjoyed our time there. So if your friends are unhappy with the unit make sure they check and see if another one is available before they move their luggage in.Paul IP: Logged |
dougp26364 TUG MemberPosts: 2187 From: Wichita KS owner: Polo Towers/ The Villas at Polo Towers/ Marriot's Ocean Point/Marriott's Grand Chateau/ HGVC LVStrip/ Grand Regency Branson, MO Registered: Jan 2001
|
posted 05-16-2005 06:53
My experiences with the reviews are that most timeshares are somewhere between the glowing reports that it was the best timeshare they've ever seen and it the reports that say it was among the worst timeshares they've ever seen.The problem with reviews is they tend to be more subjective based on the reviewer experience and background. For instance, someone new to timeshare with limited experince in TS units but has spent nights mostly in Motel 6, Days Inn's or Comfort Suites will be bowled over by any TS resort. On the other hand someone new to TS who is accustomed to accomadations at the Ritz/Carlton, JW Marriott's or any other upscale hotel with tend to be more critical about the condition of the unit, amenities and service. I sometimes think it would be helpful in the reviews if we could have a brief history of the reviewers TS background. Things like # of exchanges completed and number of years owning. I know my first reviews were more glowing and subjective and my more recent reviews have been more objective and critical. Of course, my background prior to timesharing was not taking vacations and when we did go somewhere, I'd rent the cheapest room available rather than plusher accomadations. For instance, the year we purchased into our first timeshare, we were staying at the Riviera in Vegas rather than one of the newer, nicer resorts in the middle of the strip. Of course, objective statements like the number of spiders killed, balcony table turned upside down and rusting and light fixtures missing will always draw my attention. It wouldn't matter if this was someone on thier first exchange or 300th exchange. Things like that just aren't acceptable for anyone.
[This message has been edited by dougp26364 (edited 05-16-2005).] IP: Logged |
teachingmyown TUG MemberPosts: 826 From: TN, Fairfield (points) Registered: Jan 2001
|
posted 05-16-2005 13:39
We were guests of Orange Lake last Sept via an RCI exchange. We had a three bedroom in the North village and it looked practically new. Our experiences with staff (front desk and housekeeping) were minimal but positive. As for cleanliness, the unit was nearly spotless. When we arrived there were no drip pans on the stove. (A major problem for anyone wanting to cook since it is the drip pans that support the element eyes) A quick call to the front desk and an assurance that tomorrow would be fine was all it took. (They offered to try to fix the problem that night, but it was late and we wanted to retire, not wait for maintenance to show up)I did not like the fact there are NO towel bars/hooks/shelves whatsoever within reach of the shower in the MB. No shelves inside it either (where do you people put your soap and shampoo bottle? On the floor?!) The bath itself was huge and beautiful, and the towels were folded into such pretty shapes! But, really, not a place to hang a towel or set a razor???? The screened porch was smallish, but nice. The pool was huge. One smile was the "no diving" signs posted at every pool, including the FLAT CONCRETE fountain area. (The kind where the water jets up out of the "ground"...I can't imagine anyone thinking that diving was even an option there. There wasn't even an indention holding standing water) ------------------ 4200... Every day! IP: Logged |
mjasp TUG MemberPosts: 76 From: Registered: Mar 2004
|
posted 05-16-2005 15:59
I stayed at OL last April and it was fine. I think I was in the North Village. The unit was clean, I did find a sock behind the night table which I saw when I turned off the light for the night. But that stuff happens, the housekeeping people are human. I own at Vistana and in my opinion the resorts are comparable, I prefer Vistana because of the proximity of the pools to the units in the main section (being able to walk to all the pools)As far as cleanliness, I think they are both GC worthy. Units age and like a previous poster stated, it is all relative to where you stayed before timesharing. IP: Logged |
Dana123me Non MemberPosts: 9 From: Lake Zurich, IL, USA Registered: Oct 2004
|
posted 05-16-2005 17:17
Yes, I only complained about the spiders. They replied that they would have someone come and spray. The unit was sprayed and there was a note from bug control stating that immediately after spraying the bug activity would increase for the next few days. We called and thare was nothing they would do to fix this.IP: Logged |
SydneyTugger TUG MemberPosts: 1292 From: Sydney, Australia Registered: Aug 2002
|
posted 05-16-2005 21:27
We stayed at OLCC in a 3br this past Feb and while the place looked clean, we had ants crawling all over the bedside table and the phone that was on it. That was pretty grose. Other than that, we enjoyed our time there but much preferred Summer Bay.IP: Logged |
BarCol TUG MemberPosts: 1006 From: Newmarket, Ontario, Canada Owner: 2 Aquamarine Villas, 2 Durban Sands and Foxrun! Registered: Dec 2000
|
posted 05-16-2005 23:22
Thanks for your comments all. It seems that those who stay in the North Village (where we stayed) and the East Village, and presumably the Tennis Villas - which I understand do not have Sunday check-in's - are generally happy with their units and those in the older West Village are not particularly happy. I will have to tell my friends to arrive early on the Sunday if possible and ask about unit availability in the North and East Village. As dougp (?) said, it will all depend on their experiences with accomodations before - if they have Ritz Carlton expectations then it won't be good, however if they go with Comfort Inn expectations and treat it like an adventure then it will hopefully turn out okay. The pools and the grounds should still be attractive for all visitors. ------------------ Barb IP: Logged |
SOS8260456 TUG MemberPosts: 301 From: WILKES BARRE, PA, USA Registered: May 2003
|
posted 05-17-2005 07:16
I think when you look at any vacation as an adventure, you can't go wrong. People have lousy vacations because they set their expectations too high making it impossible for anything to make them happy.I will admit though that I have hesitated to trade into OLCC because of the big difference in reviews or to even send friends to the resort. To me a truly Gold Crown resort maintains that status no matter which section you are assigned or whethor you are an owner or exchanger. If units are in need of refurbishing that badly, they should be taken out of inventory. I have also heard the same types of comments from Vistana exchangers regarding the section you are assigned makes or breaks your stay. I hestitate to trade there also. I am very happy that I have been successfull in getting trades into onsite Disney so far (we go in slow times), so I don't need to decide which off site resort to stay at. But, even onsite Disney has complaints about room locations, etc. So I guess no resort is perfect. I just keep reminding my kids that my first trip to Disney wasn't until I was 23 years old and I paid for it myself and I stayed at a COMFORT INN and I LIKED IT. It is amazing how spoiled we get. Recently I was just thrilled to get a trade into a one bedroom Disney's Old Key West and my 11 year old daughter told me she wasn't going because it wasn't a 2 bedroom - we will be sending her a postcard - lol. Bugs of any kind I would have a very hard time tolerating, especially that close to my sleeping area. The recent posts about bed bugs really give me the hives just thinking about them. One last comment, I think that alot of our friends tend to have higher expectations when we send them to our timeshares. We are always so excited about our vacations and staying in timeshares that it can't help but pump them up. This excitement then leads to higher than normal expectations that can't help but disappoint. Just some of my thoughts this beautiful May morning. Lisa IP: Logged |
timetraveler TUG MemberPosts: 589 From: Orange Lake Country Club, The Ridge of Sedona Golf Resort Registered: Mar 2001
|
posted 05-17-2005 10:12
Barb...there's way more to OL than the pools and grounds. Your friends have several onsite restaurants to pick from, golf, tennis, basketball, raquetball, goofy golf, jet skiing, tubeing,water skiing, indoor movie theater. I have yet to see a Comfort Inn offer all that. Heck, I have yet to see a Ritz Carlton offer all that. ------------------ Vickie IP: Logged |
mjasp TUG MemberPosts: 76 From: Registered: Mar 2004
|
posted 05-17-2005 13:27
OK Insect issues are entirely different than if your unit is dated or not. Getting a note left in my room that there will be an increase in insects would have had me with my luggage at the check in desk asking (politely, at first) for a bugless unit, and I have to also say that I would NOT stand for ants in my bedroom either. I can deal with older units etc etc, I have no problem with any unit (old or new) that is clean and BUGLESS.Did you guys ask them to switch your villa? IP: Logged |
3kids4me TUG MemberPosts: 4381 From: Fairfield County, CT --Owner - Smugglers' Notch - 2 bedroom, week 33 plus float-- --- I remember PJ --- Registered: Dec 2000
|
posted 05-17-2005 13:43
We had a bad experience in the Tennis Villas with regard to cleanliness. (There was black hair in the jacuzzi and on the sheets when we turned the bed down. It was disgusting.)In addition to the unclean unit, there were many maintenance issues which did get resolved, but not too quickly. We did not see any bugs. We also did not ask to be moved because they gave us a thorough clean as soon as we noticed the problems, and the maintenance issues were not enough to make us move and risk the same thing elsewhere. However, if there had been bugs we definitely would have moved!! I probably wouldn't stay at OLCC again with all of the other choices available, but if I were sending someone there, I would just tell them to check the unit thoroughly and insist on a different one if they are dissatisfied. Sharon IP: Logged |
SydneyTugger TUG MemberPosts: 1292 From: Sydney, Australia Registered: Aug 2002
|
posted 05-17-2005 16:11
We didn't ask them to move us. We just informed them hoping they'd do something about it. When the maintenance guy came up, he just had a regular can of insect spray with him and sprayed the area. I wasn't too thrilled about having the area so close to our bed sprayed as we'd be exposed to the fumes all night, but there seemed no other alternative. We just made sure the kids stayed away from the sprayed area.I did wipe down and thoroughly clean the bedside and phone as I thought there may be some invisible food residue there from the last visitors attracting the ants. We didn't ask to be moved as figure stuff like that could happen any unit, any resort. It was disconcerting, but not a big deal. The facilities weren't a big deal for us as our kids are happy with any place with a pool and playground. If we ever make it back to Orlando, we'd try a different resort.
quote: Originally posted by mjasp: OK Insect issues are entirely different than if your unit is dated or not. Getting a note left in my room that there will be an increase in insects would have had me with my luggage at the check in desk asking (politely, at first) for a bugless unit, and I have to also say that I would NOT stand for ants in my bedroom either. I can deal with older units etc etc, I have no problem with any unit (old or new) that is clean and BUGLESS.Did you guys ask them to switch your villa?
[This message has been edited by SydneyTugger (edited 05-18-2005).] IP: Logged |
sfwilshire TUG MemberPosts: 2391 From: Clinton TN Registered: Jan 2003
|
posted 05-18-2005 02:33
I don't like commercial bug sprays and won't allow our unit to be sprayed if I know they plan it. We had a nice trail of ants in our OLCC unit last summer, but just used our own bug spray to battle them.We have ants at home, too. I saw some this morning. We even have trouble with them in our van from time to time (which is why we had spray along with us) because of where we park it near the woods. Sheila IP: Logged |
timetraveler TUG MemberPosts: 589 From: Orange Lake Country Club, The Ridge of Sedona Golf Resort Registered: Mar 2001
|
posted 05-18-2005 08:41
unfortunately ants are a common pest during late spring and summer months. Not just in Florida either. And cleanliness isn't the deciding factor unfortunately. We used to get them in our kitchen every single spring, until last year we had our home treated with Termidor (sp?). YEAH....no more ants!! As far as OL goes...we always go in the early spring, and again by the first part of June, and a few more times in the fall. We've not had ants or any kind of bugs for that matter in our units, but maybe that's because of the time in which we travel.
------------------ Vickie IP: Logged |
SydneyTugger TUG MemberPosts: 1292 From: Sydney, Australia Registered: Aug 2002
|
posted 05-18-2005 16:12
Vickie, it was in the first week of February, right after the TUG cruise. Regardless, I trust that not all units get them in Winter.IP: Logged |
timetraveler TUG MemberPosts: 589 From: Orange Lake Country Club, The Ridge of Sedona Golf Resort Registered: Mar 2001
|
posted 05-18-2005 17:55
I'd have to agree with that, since I've never seen any. Thank goodness it's fairly isolated evidently.I do know that ants are a problem in Florida year round, my cousin lives in Daytona Beach and she deals with them and spiders constantly. Eeeeeuuuu! ------------------ Vickie IP: Logged |
JLB TUG MemberPosts: 7507 From: Add another 2500 posts!!! Table Rock Lake, Branson. Registered Dec. 2000 Registered: Mar 2002
|
posted 05-19-2005 05:58
I promised to be gone, but had a thought (amazing, huh).When we were there in January the bug guys were very prevalent. They came out trying to trap big spiders. Then the entire resort got sprayed, a putrid smelling something-or-other, all outside. All the grounds and the exteriors of all the buildings. It could be possible that all of the construction has displaced a lot of God's creatures. The new road is cutting right through the resort and the resort golf course is being reconfigured to accomododate it. The road is on formerly undeveloped land which would have been full of little critters and since the golf course is torn up at the same time, they couldn't just go there. The construction in the East Village and water park are a ways away, but those critters have to go somewhere too. I'll be going away again now. ------------------ 16 years timesharing/80 exchanges/Branson-Table Rock Lake boat rides Interests: Buying/Selling/Renting/Donating/Exchanging/Searching Florida/Kauai/SOCAL/Colorado/Missouri/Arkansas/Iowa/Ohio Consumer Advocacy/Estate Planning/Priceline/Hotwire/Sports/Boating/Fishing/Golf/Lake-living IP: Logged |